再エネ出力制御:2021年GWを終えて

公開日:2026-11-10

What the 2021 Golden Week Results Tell Us

The 2021 Golden Week holiday period has now passed, and for solar power plant owners in Japan, the results offer an important reality check on curtailment risk. Going into the holiday, there was speculation that renewable output curtailment might be implemented in Hokkaido and Tohoku as well as Kyushu. In the end, curtailment was actually carried out only in the Kyushu area, while the other regions escaped without control being triggered.

Kyushu Electric Power Transmission and Distribution has since updated its curtailment records, publishing the breakdown of control measures through the end of Golden Week. Comparing these figures with 2020 gives owners a clearer picture of how the operating environment is shifting.

For anyone operating a solar plant under the old rules — particularly those who secured FIT approval before the rule change — the headline is that curtailment frequency is trending upward, and the reasons are structural rather than temporary.

Curtailment Frequency Under the Old Rules

One of the most useful comparisons is the number of curtailment events under the old rules. Because the operational methodology changed in 2021, only old-rule counts are directly comparable year over year. From April through May 6, the number of control events came to roughly 8–9 times in 2020 versus 9–10 times in 2021 — essentially the same frequency.

That apparent stability deserves context, however. The reason the operating methodology was changed in the first place was that, under the previous approach, old-rule curtailment events were projected to exceed 30 times for the year. In other words, the system was adjusted precisely because the old method would have produced a sharply higher burden on old-rule generators.

Looking at the full prior fiscal year, old-rule curtailment totaled 22 events in FY2020. If the current pace continues, curtailment in the coming autumn and in March of next year is likely to exceed last year's level. One additional detail worth noting: more than 20 new plants were commissioned under the old rules between 2020 and 2021 — a surprising number that adds further pressure to the old-rule pool.

Comparing Curtailment Volume, Not Just Count

Frequency alone does not capture the full impact on revenue. The volume of curtailed energy — how much output was actually suppressed — matters just as much, and here the 2020 versus 2021 comparison is instructive. When curtailment volumes are plotted by date and sorted from smallest to largest, the pattern shows how the distribution of control events has changed, not merely how many occurred.

This matters for owners because two years with similar event counts can produce very different economic outcomes depending on the size and timing of each control event. A small number of high-volume curtailments during peak generation hours can cost more than a larger number of shallow ones.

The takeaway for owners is to track both dimensions for their own plants: how often control is applied, and how much energy is lost each time. The published records from the transmission operator make this analysis possible, but the work has to be done at the individual plant level to be meaningful.

Why the Rules Changed: Lessons from 2020 Supply and Demand

Understanding why 2021 felt different requires looking back at 2020's power supply and demand. When the operational methodology changed in April 2021, curtailment events under the designated rules increased — and many designated-rule generators were caught off guard. The common complaints were that control now occurs on consecutive days in ways that did not happen last year, and that the shift from rotating to uniform application was expected to increase frequency while reducing the control rate per event — but that reduction did not materialize as hoped.

The duration curve is a useful tool for understanding this. By reordering a year of demand data (24 hours × 365 days) from smallest to largest, independent of time, you can see how often demand sits at each level. This reframing helps explain why curtailment pressure builds even when average conditions look manageable.

The broader lesson is that curtailment is driven by the interaction of demand patterns, generation mix, and grid constraints — not by any single factor. Owners who understand this framework are better positioned to anticipate how rule changes will affect their specific plants.

The Grid Constraint Question: Does Transmission Expansion Help?

A frequent question among owners is whether transmission line reinforcement will reduce curtailment. The history is instructive. Kyushu mainland first experienced curtailment on October 13, 2018. Comparing supply and demand in April versus October 2018 during the 12:00–13:00 window shows that demand rose about 102% while supply rose about 108% — and curtailment occurs when supply exceeds demand.

Notably, curtailment in Kyushu began in autumn, even though solar generation peaks in spring. The reason lies in the generation mix: solar and thermal supply actually decreased between the two periods, but nuclear generation rose 23% as the Genkai units 3 and 4 restarted in May and July. Nuclear plants must periodically shut down for maintenance and then resume generation once maintenance is complete, which structurally adds baseload supply.

Transmission reinforcement can help alleviate constraints over time, but it is a slow lever and does not change the underlying economics of curtailment for existing plants in the near term. Owners should treat grid expansion as a long-term factor, not a solution to current control risk.

What Owners Should Do Now

The 2021 Golden Week results confirm a pattern that is unlikely to reverse on its own: curtailment in Kyushu is a recurring feature of spring and autumn operations, old-rule event counts are trending higher than last year, and the designated-rule regime has become more burdensome than many expected. For owners of sotsu-FIT plants and those preparing for 10-year inspections, this is a planning input, not just news.

The practical response is to start with accurately understanding your own plant's condition. Review your curtailment history against the transmission operator's published records, quantify both event frequency and lost generation volume, and model how a heavier curtailment year would affect your revenue and maintenance planning. Only with a clear picture of your plant's actual exposure can you make sound decisions about operations, investment, and long-term asset management.

あなたの発電所の健康状態を無料でチェック

住所または設備IDを入力するだけ。費用0円・登録1分・その場で結果表示。

無料で診断する