再エネ出力制御 2021年GW総括

公開日:2026-11-14

What Happened to Renewable Curtailment Over Golden Week 2021

Golden Week 2021 came and went with curtailment (出力制御) talk spreading well beyond Kyushu. As the holiday period approached, there was speculation that areas such as Hokkaido and Tohoku might also see renewable output controls for the first time. In the end, no curtailment was implemented in those regions, and controls were carried out only in the Kyushu area — consistent with Kyushu's position as the most advanced market for curtailment in Japan.

For solar plant owners, the important development is what came after: Kyushu Electric Power Transmission and Distribution updated its curtailment performance data, publishing the breakdown of controls through the end of Golden Week. That gives us a concrete basis to compare 2021 against 2020 and to think about what the rest of the fiscal year may hold.

This article reviews the Golden Week results, explains the rule changes behind the shifting numbers, and outlines what owners outside Kyushu should watch as curtailment risk gradually spreads. The goal is not to alarm but to help you read the data accurately — because curtailment now affects real revenue assumptions for operating plants.

Control Frequency: Old-Rule Numbers Look Similar, But Read Carefully

The first thing to note is that the counting rules themselves changed in FY2021. To make a fair comparison, we need to look at the "old rule" (旧ルール) category separately, since plants under the old rule are curtailed under different conditions than those under the new designated rule (指定ルール).

Comparing the period from April through May 6, old-rule control events came to roughly 8–9 times in 2020 and 9–10 times in 2021 — almost the same frequency year on year. On the surface, that looks reassuring. But the similarity is partly a product of the revised operating method: the new approach was introduced precisely because the previous method was projected to push old-rule control events above 30 times for the year.

That projection matters for the second half of the year. The final old-rule control count for FY2020 was 22 events. If the current pace continues, the autumn period and March 2022 could see more controls than the previous fiscal year. In other words, a quiet Golden Week does not mean a quiet year.

One more detail worth noting: between 2020 and 2021, more than 20 new projects were commissioned under the old rule. That is a surprising number given how long the old rule has existed, and it means the old-rule pool is not shrinking as fast as some assumed. More capacity under the old rule means more potential exposure when supply outstrips demand.

Behind the Shift: Why Designated-Rule Operators Saw More Controls

April 2021 brought a change to how Kyushu Electric applies curtailment, and designated-rule generators noticed quickly. The complaints were consistent: controls that never happened last year now arrive on consecutive days, and the switch from rotation-based (輪番) to uniform (一律) treatment did not reduce the intensity of each control event as some had expected.

Understanding why requires thinking about how surplus supply accumulates. One useful lens is the duration curve — a way of sorting a year's demand data (24 hours × 365 days) from smallest to largest, independent of time. When you line demand up this way, you can see how many hours of the year fall below a given level, and therefore how much renewable output the system can absorb before curtailment becomes necessary.

When supply capacity rises — for example, as nuclear units return to service after maintenance — the whole supply curve shifts up. Solar output peaks in spring, when demand is moderate, so the margin for absorption narrows. The change in operating method was a response to this tighter margin: spreading controls more evenly across the designated-rule fleet rather than relying on rotation. The practical effect for owners is that curtailment is no longer a rare event concentrated in a few windows; it can appear in clusters.

For investors modeling revenue, this argues for treating curtailment as a recurring line item rather than an exceptional one, at least in Kyushu.

How Curtailment Began in Kyushu — and What Transmission Upgrades Can and Cannot Fix

It is worth remembering the starting point. The first curtailment on the Kyushu mainland was implemented on Saturday, October 13, 2018. Comparing supply and demand for the 12:00–13:00 window in April versus October of that year, average demand rose about 2% while supply rose about 8%. The driver was not solar — solar and thermal supply actually fell. The increase came from nuclear: Genkai Units 3 and 4 restarted in May and July respectively, adding roughly 23% more nuclear output.

This illustrates a structural point. Curtailment happens when supply exceeds demand, and in Kyushu the supply side is dominated by baseload nuclear that runs regardless of the season. Solar peaks in spring, but the system constraint is set by the total mix. That is why curtailment began in autumn 2018 rather than spring.

Transmission interconnection (連系線) reinforcement is often proposed as the solution. Additional capacity to move power to other regions would undoubtedly help at the margin, but it is a slow, capital-intensive remedy, and it does not change the underlying economics of surplus generation within the region. Owners should treat interconnection expansion as a long-term easing factor, not a near-term fix, and should not build revenue plans around it arriving on schedule.

What This Means for Solar Owners Going Forward

The Golden Week 2021 data points to three practical takeaways. First, Kyushu remains the only region where curtailment was actually implemented, but the speculation around Hokkaido and Tohoku signals that the conversation is widening. Owners in those regions should monitor their utility's supply-demand publications rather than assume curtailment is someone else's problem.

Second, the rule category of your plant matters enormously. Old-rule and designated-rule plants face different curtailment conditions, and the FY2021 method change altered the pattern of controls for designated-rule operators. Knowing which rule applies to your plant — and how that rule has been applied in practice — is the foundation of any realistic output forecast.

Third, a mild curtailment season is not evidence of a mild trend. FY2020 ended with 22 old-rule events; the current pace suggests more in the months ahead. If your financial model still assumes zero or negligible curtailment, this is the moment to revisit it with actual utility data rather than assumptions.

None of this requires panic. It requires accuracy. Start by accurately understanding your plant's condition: confirm your rule category, pull your utility's published curtailment records for your area, and compare them against your own generation logs. Only then can you judge whether your revenue assumptions still hold — and what, if anything, you need to change.

あなたの発電所の健康状態を無料でチェック

住所または設備IDを入力するだけ。費用0円・登録1分・その場で結果表示。

無料で診断する